How to grill a thick Wagyu steak

A thick Wagyu steak needs little more than salt and a good fire. Cook it gently until the center is nearly done, then sear both sides for a deep brown crust.

Jump to recipe

Raw New York strip, ribeye and center-cut filet on pale butcher paper, from left to right.
From left to right, New York strip, ribeye and filet. Look for fine white streaks of fat running through the meat.

At the butcher counter

If you’re splurging on steak, a local butcher is worth the trip. Ask for a boneless American Wagyu strip or ribeye cut 1½ to 2 inches thick. One steak weighing about a pound makes dinner for two. A cut that thick gives you time to brown both sides while the middle stays pink.

A grocery store with a full-service meat counter may also cut one to order. If you’re buying online, Snake River Farms sells all three cuts below.

New York strip. A good first pick. Its even shape makes it easy to turn. Hold the strip on its fatty edge with tongs for a few seconds at the end to brown it.

Ribeye. Pick this one if the browned, fatty bites are your favorite. The curved strip around the eye is especially rich. Aim your thermometer at the meaty center, clear of the fat seam.

Filet. The round tenderloin steak has a milder flavor and a buttery texture. Buy center-cut pieces of similar thickness and check each one separately.

If the butcher offers Japanese A5, save that extra-rich beef for another night. It’s lovely in small portions seared in a skillet.

How your grill affects the steak

On a charcoal kettle, bank the coals on one side. Cook the steak on the empty side at 225–250°F, then move it over the coals. The drippings hit the fire and give the crust its smoky flavor.

A Big Green Egg gives you that same charcoal sear. Its ceramic walls hold a steady heat, so the center cooks evenly. Start at 250°F with the heat deflector in place. To sear, lift the steak out, remove the deflector with heatproof gloves and bring the Egg to about 550°F.

On a Traeger, the steak picks up a light wood-smoke flavor as it cooks at 225°F. For an even crust, lift the steak out and let a cast-iron skillet heat up on the grill’s high setting. Sear both sides in the hot pan. If you finish the steak on the stove, compare cast iron and stainless steel for searing.

How to grill the steak

Save on Pinterest

Have kosher salt, long tongs and an instant-read thermometer handy. With a thick steak, the thermometer makes it easy to get the center just how you like it.

Choose your doneness

Use the steak doneness tool to compare temperatures, check your thermometer reading, and time the rest.

We like medium for a thick Wagyu steak. At 145°F, the center is warm and pink. Measure in the middle of the meat and use these typical finished temperatures as a guide.

DonenessCenter temperatureCenter color
Rare125°FRed
Medium-rare135°FReddish pink
Medium145°FPink throughout
Medium-well150°FA little pink
Well-done160°FLittle or no pink

Rare and medium-rare fall below the USDA minimum for whole beef steaks. Its guidance is to reach 145°F on the grill and rest for at least 3 minutes. The center can warm a few more degrees as the steak rests.

1. Salt both faces and the edges

Pat the steak dry and sprinkle it evenly with kosher salt. If you’re planning ahead, salt it the night before and refrigerate it uncovered on a rack over a rimmed tray. Otherwise, salt it just before grilling.

Watercolor of a cook sprinkling salt over a thick steak on a rack over a rimmed tray.

2. Warm the center over gentle heat

Set the steak over indirect heat and close the lid. Start checking after 20 minutes. Slip an instant-read thermometer in from the side so the tip reaches the middle. For medium, move the steak to high heat when the center reaches about 130°F. The sear will take it the rest of the way.

Watercolor of a kettle grill with coals on the left and a steak on the empty side of the grate.
On a kettle, leave the space under the steak free of coals. Close the lid once the steak is in place.

3. Sear until the crust is deep brown

Move the steak over the coals or into the hot skillet. Turn it about every 30 seconds. If dripping fat sends up flames, move the steak clear until they settle. For medium, take the steak off when the center reaches 145°F. If the crust browns first, move the steak back to gentle heat to finish. For medium-well or well-done, keep it there until it reaches your chosen temperature.

Two watercolor views of a thick strip steak, tan after indirect cooking on the left and deep brown after searing on the right.
After gentle heat, the surface is dry and tan (left). Sear both sides until the crust is deep brown (right).

4. Rest, slice and share

Rest the steak on a clean board for 5 minutes. Cut across the grain and spoon any juices over the slices. Bring the board straight to the table while the crust is still warm.

Close-up of one browned New York strip with three generous slices on a wooden carving board.